Assessment of different physicochemical parameters of leachates from two locally unbranded yogurt containers in Erbil City, Kurdistan Region, Iraq

Exposure of humans to toxic chemicals can lead to significant health risks. This study evaluates the physicochemical parameters in the leachates of two local yogurt containers purchased from Erbil City, Iraq, comprising white plastic (WPC) and aluminum containers (ALC). Acetic acid, distilled water, ethanol, lactic acid, sodium carbonate, and sodium chloride at varying concentrations were examined as effective simulants for assessing leaching from the two containers (1.0 cm2 container/1.0 mL simulant). Leaching experiments were conducted under three different conditions, including Refrigerated/First Condition (1stC, 4±1°C for 72 hours), Ambient/Second Condition (2ndC, 25±2°C for 24 hours), and Elevated/Third Condition (3rdC, 60±2°C for 2 hours). After leaching, many tests, such as the change in physical state, pH measurement, estimation of leached oxidizable materials, UV absorbing materials (UV-AMs), weight loss (WL), and heavy metals (HMs) level, were examined for the obtained leachates. The observations showed that there was a significant change in the ALC specimens’ surface. Most of the analyzed HMs were found in levels below the permissible limits (1000 μg/L), except the content of lead was found above this limit in the ALC leachates using 5% sodium carbonate. The results showed that the maximum migration level of oxidizable matters and UV-AMs was observed in the leachates of ALC (3rdC, 5% sodium carbonate) and WPC (1stC and 2ndC, lactic acid), respectively. The WL was additionally recorded at a high level in many kinds of local yogurts. Results exceeded many international guidelines and clearly confirm that the continuous use of the ALC and WPC may contribute significantly to the daily intake of toxic chemicals and can pose a significant health hazard.

Al-Malaika S, Axtell F, Rothon R, Gilbert M, 2017. Additives for plastics, chapter 7. In: Brydson’s plastics materials, (eighth edition). Gilber M, ed. Elsevier, Amsterdam, Netherlands, pp. 127-68.

Al Juhaiman LA, 2010. Estimating aluminum leaching from aluminum cook wares in different meat extracts and milk. J Saudi Chem Soc 14:131-7.

Al Juhaiman LA, 2012. Estimating aluminum leaching from aluminum cookware in different vegetable extracts. Int J Electrochem Sci 7:7283-94.

Al Zubaidy EA, Mohammad FS, Bassioni G, 2011. Effect of pH, salinity and temperature on aluminum cookware leaching during food preparation. Int J Electrochem Sci 6:6424-41.

Alabi OA, Adeoluwa YM, 2020. Production usage, and potential public health effects of aluminum cookware: a review. Ann Sci Technol 5:20-30.

Ali HA, Ali A, 2023. Aluminum leaching during food preparation and storage. J Food Dairy Sci 14:93-7.

Ali HS, Almashhadany DA, Khalid HS, 2020. Determination of heavy metals and selenium content in chicken liver at Erbil city, Iraq. Ital J Food Saf 9:8659.

Almashhadany DA, Khalid HS, Ali HS, 2020. Determination of heavy metals and selenium contents in fish meat sold at Erbil City, Kurdistan Region, Iraq. Ital J Food Saf 9:8753.

Ammar HR, Saleh SM, Sivasankaran S, Albadri AE, Al-Mufadi FA, 2023. Investigation of Element Migration from Aluminum Cooking Pots Using ICP-MS. Appl Sci 13:13119.

Charkiewicz AE, Omeljaniuk WJ, Nowak K, Garley M, Nikliński J, 2023. Cadmium toxicity and health effects—a brief summary. Molecules 28:6620.

Costa MP, Frasao BS, Costa-Lima BRC, Rodrigues BL, Junior CAC, 2016. Simultaneous analysis of carbohydrates and organic acids by HPLC-DAD-RI for monitoring goat’s milk yogurts fermentation. Talanta 152:162-70.

Costa MP, Junior CAC, 2015. Chromatographic methods for the determination of carbohydrates and organic acids in foods of animal origin. Compr Rev Food Sci Food Saf 14:586-600.

Crisponi G, Fanni D, Gerosa C, Nemolato S, Nurchi VM, Crespo-Alonso M, Lachowicz JI, Faa G, 2013. The meaning of aluminium exposure on human health and aluminium-related diseases. Biomol concepts 4:77-87.

EFSA, 2008. Safety of aluminium from dietary intake‐scientific opinion of the panel on food additives, flavourings, processing aids and food contact materials (AFC). EFSA J 6:754.

EFSA, 2011. On the evaluation of a new study related to the bioavailability of aluminium in food. EFSA J 11:2157.

European Council, 2013. Metals and alloys used in food contact materials and articles: a practical guide for manufacturers and regulators: A technical guide for manufacturers and regulators, France, EC for FCM and Articles (CD-P-MCA) EDQM.

Exley C, Korchazhkina OV, 2001. Promotion of formation of amyloid fibrils by aluminium adenosine triphosphate (AlATP). J Inorg Biochem 84:215-24.

Fekete V, Vandevijvere S, Bolle F, Van Loco J, 2013. Estimation of dietary aluminum exposure of the Belgian adult population: evaluation of contribution of food and kitchenware. Food Chem Toxicol 55:602-8.

Fermo P, Soddu G, Miani A, Comite V, 2020. Quantification of the aluminum content leached into foods baked using aluminum foil. Int J Environ Res Public Health 17:8357.

Hardisson A, Revert C, Gonzales-Weler D, Rubio C, 2017. Aluminium exposure through the diet. Food Sci. Nutr 3:19.

Inan‐Eroglu E, Gulec A, Ayaz A, 2018. Determination of aluminium leaching into various baked meats with different types of foils by ICP‐MS. J Food Process Preserv 42:e13771.

IS, 1998. Determination of overall migration of constituents of plastics materials and articles intended to come in contact with food stuffs–Method of Analysis. Bureau of Indian Standards, No IS 9845.

Jalal AF, Khalid HS, Yasin IT, Xanamir MR, 2020. Estimation of some metals in children’s colorful modeling clay sold in the markets of Erbil City, Kurdistan Region, Iraq. Zanco J Pure Appl Sci 32:134-45.

Khalid HS, Ali HS, Almashhadany DA, 2020. Metalliferous content of drinking water and sediments in storage tanks of some schools in Erbil city, Iraq. Ital J Food Saf 9:8862.

Khalid HS, Hamadamin SS, Salih HS, 2020. Assessment of risk behaviors and toxic heavy metals exposure of car dye workers in repairing services in Erbil City, Kurdistan Region, Iraq. Zanco J Pure Appl Sci 32:1-13.

Khalid HS, Jalal AF, Khdr KW, Ahmad MO, 2020. Determination of some heavy metals in environment of bakery and samoon furnaces at Erbil City, Kurdistan Region, Iraq. Zanco J Pure Appl Sci 32:176-86.

Khalid HS, Jalal AF, Mohammed HF, Sharef HY, Fakhre NA, 2024. Quantification of selected heavy metals through inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometry in containers of yogurts used in Erbil City, Krg, Iraq. Bull Chem Soc Ethiop 38:1509-19.

Khan S, Khan A, 2015. Toxic heavy metal contamination in locally made plastic food container. Int J Sci Eng Res 6:45-7.

Lahimer MC, Ayed N, Horriche J, Belgaied S, 2017. Characterization of plastic packaging additives: Food contact, stability and toxicity. Arab J Chem 10:S1938-S54.

Li R, Ding Q, Zhao X-H, 2019. Impact of milk fortification on the microbiological and physicochemical properties of set-type skimmed yoghurt using three commercial soluble prebiotics. Foods 8:181.

Maske MPD, Shivankar MVT, Raut MLR, Badwaik MCB, Lade MUB, 2024. Water quality in different storage containers: a comparative study of materials. IJPRA 9:920-3.

Matela K, Pillai MK, Thamae T, 2019. Evaluation of pH, titratable acidity, syneresis and sensory profiles of some yoghurt samples from the kingdom of Lesotho. Food Research 3:693-7.

Merkel S. German research project on “Aluminium Release from Food Packaging”. 3rd meeting Food Ingredients and Packaging (FIP) scientific network for the cooperation and harmonisation of risk assessment of food contact materials, 2016-05-24/2016-05-25, EFSA, Parma, Italy, 2016.

MFDSK, 2021. Standards and specifications for utensils, containers and packages. Korea: MFDS (No. 2021-76).

Mohammad F, Al Zubaidy E, Bassioni G, 2011. Effect of aluminum leaching process of cooking wares on food. Int J Electrochem Sci 6:222-30.

Mukherjee AG, Renu K, Gopalakrishnan AV, Veeraraghavan VP, Vinayagam S, Paz-Montelongo S, Dey A, Vellingiri B, George A, Madhyastha H, 2023. Heavy metal and metalloid contamination in food and emerging technologies for its detection. Sustain 15:1195.

Nasibullah M, Ahmad N, Hassan F, Khan AR, Patel DK, 2014. Evaluation of physicochemical parameters of the leachates of plastic biomedical devices. Adv Sci Focus 2:1-7.

Ncube LK, Ude AU, Ogunmuyiwa EN, Zulkifli R, Beas IN, 2020. Environmental impact of food packaging materials: A review of contemporary development from conventional plastics to polylactic acid based materials. Materials 13:4994.

Nguyen VT, Linh TTT, Vo TK, Nguyen QH, Van TK, 2023. Analytical techniques for determination of heavy metal migration from different types of locally made plastic food packaging materials using ICP‐MS. Food Sci Nutr 11:4030-7.

Niu Q, 2018. Overview of the relationship between aluminum exposure and health of human being. Adv Exp Med Biol 1091:1-31.

Ochmański W, Barabasz W, 2000. Aluminum--occurrence and toxicity for organisms. Przegl Lek 57:665-8.

Parashar N, Hait S, 2021. Plastics in the time of COVID-19 pandemic: protector or polluter? Sci Total Environ 759:144274.

Parkar J, Rakesh M, 2014. Leaching of elements from packaging material into canned foods marketed in India. Food control 40:177-84.

Puligundla P, Ko S, 2013. Chemical leachates from food contact packaging materials and health risks. Food Eng Prog 17:99-104.

Ranjan VP, Joseph A, Goel S, 2021. Microplastics and other harmful substances released from disposable paper cups into hot water. J Hazard Mater 404:124118.

Roy S, Ramakrishnan R, Goksen G, Singh S, Łopusiewicz Ł, 2024. Recent progress on UV-light barrier food packaging films–a systematic review. Innov Food Sci Emerg Technol 91:103550.

Shamloo E, Nickfar F, Mahmoudzadeh M, Sarafraz M, Salari A, Darroudi M, Abdi-Moghadam Z, Amiryosefi MR, Rezagholizade-Shirvan A, Rezaei Z, 2024. Investigation of heavy metal release from variety cookware into food during cooking process. Int J Environ Anal Chem 104:8085-101.

Shrinithivihahshini ND, Mahamuni D. 2024. A study based on BIS standard IS9845: 1998 for assessing the migration of bisphenol A from food contact plastics. Available from: https://www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-4363762/v1.

Soni MG, White SM, Flamm WG, Burdock GA, 2001. Safety evaluation of dietary aluminum. Regul Toxicol Pharmacol 33:66-79.

United States Pharmacopeia. 1995. The National Formulary. USP-23. Untied State Pharmacopoeial Convention, Inc.,12601., 1995 Twinbrook Parkway, Rockville, MD 20852.

Vincoff S, Schleupner B, Santos J, Morrison M, Zhang N, Dunphy-Daly MM, Eward WC, Armstrong AJ, Diana Z, Somarelli JA, 2024. The known and unknown: Investigating the carcinogenic potential of plastic additives. Environ Sci Technol 58:10445-57.

Zeng X, Liu D, Wu Y, Zhang L, Chen R, Li R, Gu W, Zhang L, Liu C, Sun Q, 2023. Heavy metal risk of disposable food containers on human health. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf 255:114797.