Ecological connectivity of bee communities in fragmented areas of Volcano Etna (Sicily, Italy) at different degrees of anthropogenic disturbance (Hymenoptera, Apoidea, Anthophila)

Published: 23 May 2023
Abstract Views: 2257
PDF: 754
Supplementary material: 218
Publisher's note
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.


The present study analyses the ecological connectivity of four bee communities in fragmented areas in the foothills of Volcano Etna (Catania province, Sicily, Italy). The surveys were carried out in four sites under different land management regimes from 2007 to 2010. The selected areas include two different urban parks in the city of Catania (Parco Gioeni and Parco degli Ulivi), a Nature Reserve (Complesso Immacolatelle e Micio Conti, San Gregorio di Catania), and an agroecosystem (a citrus orchard, Aci Catena). The well-known bee community of a suburban park (Timpa di Leucatia, north of Catania) was considered as a control site. The bee communities include 163 species, belonging to the families Colletidae (10 species), Andrenidae (27 spp.), Halictidae (31 spp.), Melittidae (1 sp.), Megachilidae (49 spp.), and Apidae (45 spp.). Comparative zoocenotic analyses have been carried out, by calculating the main diversity indices and different methods of multivariate analysis. The ecological connectivity was evaluated through cartographic instruments by mapping the level of biopermeability of the foothills of Etna, to highlight how the level of naturality and ecological corridors could affect bee diversity. Furthermore, the degree of environmental fragmentation was evaluated through the biogeographic model of islands under the linear regression species-area, considering the examined sites as “ecological islands”. The data obtained highlight that reliable conservation strategies should consider firstly the maintenance of adequate ecological connectivity among environmental patches as well a high degree of local biodiversity, especially a high diversity of flowering plants.



PlumX Metrics


Download data is not yet available.


AIZEN M.A., FEINSINGER R., 1994 - Habitat fragmentation, native insect pollinators, and feral honey bees in Argentine “Chaco Serrano”. - Ecol. Appl., 4:378-392. DOI:
BELLA S., MUSMECI M., 2004 - Catania Verde: un modo diverso per conoscere la città. - Cavallotto Edizioni: 48 pp.
BELLA S., CATANIA R., NOBILE V., MAZZEO G., 2020 - New or little known bees (Hymenoptera, Apoidea) from Sicily. - Fragmenta entomologica, 52 (1): 113-117. DOI:
BUCHHOLZ S., EGERER M.H., 2020 - Functional ecology of wild bees in cities: towards a better understanding of traiturbanization relationships. - Biodivers. Conserv., 2779-2801. DOI:
CANE J.H., 2001 - Habitat fragmentation and native bees: a premature verdict? - Conserv. Ecol., 5. DOI:
VAISSIÈRE B.E., 2009 - Landscape context and habitat type as drivers of bee diversity in European annual crops. - Agric. Ecosyst. Environ., 133: 40-47. DOI:
CIACCIA C., LA TORRE A., FERLITO F., TESTANI E., BATTAGLIA V., SALVATI L., ROCCUZZO G., 2019 - Agroecological practices and agrobiodiversity: a case study on organic orange in southern Italy. - Agron., 9 (85): 2-13. DOI:
CLARKE K.R., WARWICK R.M., 2001 - Change in marine communities: an approach to statistical analysis and interpretation, 2nd edition. - Plymouth Marine Laboratory, PRIMER-E Ltd, Plymouth. pp. 234.
CONNOR E.F., COURTNEY A.C., YODER M., 2000 - Individuals-area relationships: The relationship between animal population density and area. - Ecol., 81: 734-748. DOI:[0734:IARTRB]2.0.CO;2
CORBET S.A., WILLIAMS I.H., OSBORNE J.L., 1991 - Bees and the pollination of crops and wild flowers in the European Community. - Bee World, 72: 47-59. DOI:
COUTINHO J.G.E., HIPÒLITO J., SANTOS E.L.S., MOREIRA E.F., BOSCOLO D., VIANA B.L., 2021 - Landscape structure is a major driver of bee functional diversity in crops. - Front. Ecol. Evol., 9: 1-13. DOI:
CUSSER S., GRANDO C., ZUCCHI M., LÓPEZ-URIBE M., POPE N.S., BALLARE K.M., LUNA-LUCENA D., ALMEIDA E.A., NEFF J., YOUNG K., JHA S., 2019 - Small but critical: semi-natural habitat fragments promote bee abundance in cotton agroecosystems across both Brazil and the United States. - Landsc. Ecol., 34: 1825-1836. DOI:
DANFORTH B.N., MINCKLEY R.L., NEFF J.L., 2019 - The Solitary Bees: Biology, Evolution, Conservation. - Princeton University Press, ed. Princeton and Oxford, 488 pp. DOI:
DAVIES K.F., MARGULES C.R., LAWRENCE J.F., 2000 - Which traits of species predict population declines in experimental forest fragments? - Ecol., 81: 1450-1461. DOI:[1450:WTOSPP]2.0.CO;2
DIGBY P.G.N., KEMPTON R.A., 1987 - Multivariate analysis of ecological communities. - Chapman & Hall, London: 207 pp. DOI:
DOBSON A., RALLS K., FOSTER M., SOULÉ M.E., SIMBERLOFF D., DOAK D., ESTES J.A., MILLS L.S., MATTSON D., DIRZO R., ARITA H., RYAN S., NORSE E.A., NOSS R.F., JOHNS D., 1999 - Corridors: reconnecting fragmented landscapes. - In: Soulé M.E., Terborgh J. (eds.). Continental Conservation. The Wildland Project. Island Press, Washington D.C.: 129-170.
D’URSO V., SIRACUSA G., LICCIARDELLO G., TOMASELLI G., 2001 - Il ruolo degli agrumeti etnei e dei manufatti edilizi connessi nella costruzione delle reti ecologiche periurbane. La biodiversità nei paesaggi agrari e forestali. - Collana Siciliana
Foreste, 15: 99-126.
FERREIRA P.A., BOSCOLO D., CARVALHEIRO L.G., BIESMEIJER J.C., DA ROCHA P.L.B., VIANA, B.F., 2015 - Responses of bees to habitat loss in fragmented landscapes of Brazilian Atlantic Rainforest. - Landsc. Ecol., 30: 2067-2078. DOI:
FERREIRA C.B., MEZONDA C.P.J., COSTA M.B.P., 2019 - Effects of habitat loss in the comunity of wild bees. - Revista de Agroecologia, 3 (2): 1-7. DOI:
FUSSELL M., CORBET S.A., 1992 - Flower usage by bumblebees: a basis for forage plant management. - J. Appl. Ecol., 29: 451-465. DOI:
GATHMANN A., TSCHARNTKE T., 2002 - Foraging range of solitary bees. - J. Anim. Ecol., 71: 757-764. DOI:
GIBB H., HOCHULI D.F., 2002 - Habitat fragmentation in an urban environment: large and small fragments support different DOI:
arthropod assemblages. - Biol. Conserv., 106 (1): 91-100.
GOULSON D., HUGHES W.O.H., DERWENT L.C., STOUT J.C., 2002 - Colony growth of the bumblebee, Bombus terrestris, in improved and conventional agricultural and suburban habitats. - Oecologia, 130: 267-273. DOI:
GREENLEAF S.S., WILLIAMS N.M., WINFREE R., KREMEN C., 2007 - Bee foraging ranges and their relationship to body size. - Oecologia, 153: 589-596. DOI:
HANSKI I., 1999 - Habitat connectivity, habitat continuity, and metapopulation in dynamic landscapes. - Oikos, 87: 209-219. DOI:
HENLE K., DAVIES K.F., KLEYER M., MARGULES C., SETTELE J., 2004 - Predictors of species sensitivity to fragmentation. - Biodivers. Conserv., 13: 207-251. DOI:
HERNANDEZ J.L., FRANKIE G.W., THORP R.W., 2009 - Ecology of urban bees: a review of current knowledge and directions for future study. - Cities and the Environment, 2 (1):3-15. DOI:
HOLT R.D., LAWTON J.H., POLLS G.A., MARTINEZ N.M., 1999 - Trophic rank and the species-area relationship. - Ecol., 80: 1495-1504. DOI:[1495:TRATSA]2.0.CO;2
HUNG K.L.J., ASCHER J.S., DAVIDS J.A., HOLWAY D.A., 2019 - Ecological filtering in scrub fragments restructures the taxonomic and functional composition of native bee assemblages. - Ecol., 100 (5): e02654. DOI:
JAMES F.C., MCCULLOCH C.E., 1990 - Multivariate analysis in ecology and systematics: Panacea or pandora’s box? - Annu. Rev. Ecol. Syst, 21: 129-166. DOI:
LA POINT S., BALKENHOL N., HALE J., SADLER J., VAN DER REE R., 2015 - Ecological connectivity research in urban areas. - Funct. Ecol., 29: 868-878. DOI:
LAS CASAS G., CIACCIA C., IOVINO V., FERLITO F., TORRISI B., LODOLINI E.M., GIUFFRIDA A., CATANIA R., NICOLOSI E., BELLA S., 2022 - Effects of different inter-row soil management and intra-row living mulch on spontaneous flora, beneficial insects and growth of young olive trees in Southern Italy. - Plants, 11, 545. DOI:
LONGO S., 2002 - Ruolo degli agroecosistemi nella conservazione della biodiversità. - Tecnica Agricola, 3-4: 73-79.
MACARTHUR R.H., WILSON E.O., 1967 - The theory of Island Biogeography. - Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. 203 p.
MASSIMINO COCUZZA G.E., MAZZEO G., RUSSO A., LO GIUDICE V., BELLA S., 2016 - Pomegranate arthropod pests and their management in the Mediterranean area. - Phytoparasitica, 44 (3): 393-409. DOI:
MATHESON A., BUCHMANN S.L., O’TOOLE C., WESTRICH P., WILLIAMS I.H., 1996 - The conservation Biology of bees London. - Academic Press: 252 pp.
MAZZEO G., LONGO S., BELLA S., 1999 - Il censimento dei pronubi in Sicilia. - Tecnica Agricola, 4: 67-75.
MAZZEO G., LONGO S., PALMERI V., BELLA S., 2001 - Anthophilous insect indicating biodiversity in natural and cultivated sicilian environments. - Insect Soc. Life, 4: 93-100.
MAZZEO G., LONGO S., BELLA S., 2002 - I pronubi rivelati su colture minori in Sicilia orientale. - Atti XIX Congresso Nazionale di Entomologia, Catania 10-15 giugno: 1275-1280.
MAZZEO G., LONGO S., PALMERI V., SEMINARA A., BELLA S., ZAPPALÀ L., 2004 - Anthophilous insect in fruit orchards on mount Etna (Italy). - Redia, 88: 247-251.
MAZZEO G., LONGO S., SEMINARA A., BELLA S., FERRAUTO G., 2007 - Prelimirary observations on anthophilous insect and foraging behaviour of Apis mellifera L. in a protected area of the Etna park. - Redia, 90: 109-113.
MAZZEO G., BELLA S., SEMINARA A.R., LONGO S., 2015 - Bumblebees in natural and agro-ecosystems at different altitudes
from Mount Etna, Sicily (Hymenoptera Apidae Bombinae): long-term faunistic and ecological observations. - Redia, XCVIII: 123-131.
MAZZEO G., LONGO S., SEMINARA A.R., BELLA S., 2019 - Faunistic and ecological studies on Apidae (Hymenoptera, Apoidea) in natural and cultivated ecosystems in Sicily. - Redia, 102: 153-162. DOI:
PORRINI C., RADEGHIERI P., ROMAGNOLI F., VERSARI S., 1998 - I pronubi selvatici come indicatori della biocomplessità
ambientale. - Atti XVII Congr. Naz. it. Ent., Maratea 21-26 giugno 1998.
RUIU L., SATTA A., ZANDIGIACOMO P., 2004 - Wild bees in agroecosystems and semi-natural landscapes. - Bull. Insectology, 57 (1): 11-61.
RICKETTS T.H., 2001 - The matrix matters: Effective isolation in fragmented landscapes. - Am. Nat., 158: 87-99. DOI:
ROSENZWEIG M.L., 1995 - Species diversity in space and time. - Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. DOI:
SEMINARA A., BELLA S., MAZZEO G., LONGO S., 2009 - Risultati di un triennio di studi sugli insetti antofili in un biotopo del vulcano Etna. - Apoidea, 6: 27-35.
SENAPATHI D., GODDARD M.A., KUNIN W.E., BALDOCK K.C.R., 2017 - Landscape impacts on pollinator communities in temperate systems: evidence and knowledge gaps. - Funct. Ecol., 31: 26-37. DOI:
STEFFAN-DEWENTER I., 2003 - Importance of habitat area and landscape context for species richness of bees and wasps in fragmented orchard meadows. - Conserv. Biol., 17 (4): 1036-1044. DOI:
STEFFAN-DEWENTER I., KLEIN A.-M., GAEBELE V., ALFERT T., TSCHARNTKE T., 2006 - Bee diversity and plant-pollinator interactions in fragmented landscapes. - In: WASER N.M. & OLLERTON J., Plant-pollinator interactions, from specialization to generalization. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London: 387-407.
STEFFAN-DEWENTER I., TSCHARNTKE T., 1999 - Effects of habitat isolation on pollinator communities and seed set. - Oecologia, 121: 432-440. DOI:
STEFFAN-DEWENTER I., TSCHARNTKE T., 2002 - Insect communities and biotic interactions on fragmented calcareous grasslands - a mini review. - Biol. Conserv., 104: 275-284. DOI:
TERAYAMA M., MURATA K., 1990 - Effects of area fragmentation of forests for nature conservation: analysis by ant communities. - Bull. Biogeogr. Soc. Jpn., 45 (1-22): 11-17.
THEODOROU P., HERBST S.-C., KAHNT B., LANDAVERDEGONZÁLEZ P., BALTZ L.M., OSTERMAN J., PAXTON R.J., 2020 - Urban fragmentation leads to lower floral diversity, with knock-on impacts on bee biodiversity. - Sci. Rep., 10:21756. DOI:
TSCHARNTKE T., STEFFAN-DEWENTER I., KRUESS A., THIES C, 2002 - Characteristics of insect populations on habitat fragments: A mini review. - Ecol. Res., 17: 229-239. DOI:
TURRISI G.F., BELLA S., CATANIA R., LA GRECA P., NOBILE V., D’URSO V., 2021 - Bee diversity in fragmented areas of Volcano Etna (Sicily, Italy) at different degrees of anthropic disturbance (Hymenoptera: Apoidea, Anthophila). - J Entomol. Acarol. Res., 53 (2): 10362. DOI:
VIELI L., MURÚA M.M., FLORES-PRADO L., CARVALLO G.O., VALDIVIA C.E., MUSCHETT G., LÓPEZ-ALISTE M., ANDÍA C., JOFRÉ-PÉREZ C., FONTÚRBEL F.E., 2021 - Local Actions to Tackle a Global Problem: A Multidimensional Assessment of the Pollination Crisis in Chile. - Diversity, 13, 571. DOI:
VILLALTA I., BOUGET C., LOPEZ-VAAMONDE C., BAUDE M., 2022 - Phylogenetic, functional and taxonomic responses of wild bee communities along urbanisation gradients. - Science of the Total Environment, 832: 154926. DOI:
WESTRICH P., 1990 - Die wildbienen Baden-Württembergs. - Ulmer Verlag, Stuttgart, 1, 2: 972 pp.
WILCOVE D.S., MCLELLAN C.H., DOBSON A.P., 1986 - Habitat fragmentation in the temperate zones. - In: Soulé M.E. (ed.). Conserv. Biol. Sinauer Associates Inc. Sunderland, Massachusetts: 237-256.
WINFREE R., AGUILAR R., VAZQUEZ D.P., LE BUHN G., AIZEN M., 2009 - A meta-analysis of bees’ responses to anthropogenic disturbance. - Ecol., 90 (8): 2068-2076. DOI:

How to Cite

Bella, S., Catania, R., La Greca, P., Nobile, V., Turrisi, G. F., & D’Urso, V. (2023). Ecological connectivity of bee communities in fragmented areas of Volcano Etna (Sicily, Italy) at different degrees of anthropogenic disturbance (Hymenoptera, Apoidea, Anthophila). Journal of Entomological and Acarological Research, 55(1).